There are two different eyecups. The longer (deeper) one is very soft and tears very easily. I finally bought several of the shorter, tougher ones from Hasselblad service ... they change easily in a minute or two if you have the correct screw driver. Since buying the shorter, tougher ones, I haven't had to replace one.

Bill
But your nose is always on the backscreen with the shorter eyecup, and so the skinfat also, I hate smudgy screens. Sry, thats not a alternative solution for me maybe for somebody else.